I speak to XX. I send him an e-mail asking if Judge ERIC VITALIANO was ever fined by the Sanitation department . I told him over the phone that I had written a letter to Chief X at 1824 Bay Parkway but I never got a response to his letter. He tells me that he has to consult his legal staff. He calls me a little after 3 PM to say that Judge ERIC VITALIANO has no fines as far back as their records go. He never says how far back their records go. He tells me to double check with the Environmental Control Board.